Vancouver Canucks: 3 Trade Proposals for Matt Duchene

The Canucks want a top-line centre, the Avalanche want defence — it’s a perfect fit.

It is no secret that the Vancouver Canucks will need a successor for franchise centre Henrik Sedin. And they will need one soon.

In most cases, the only way to get one is through the draft. Players like Sidney Crosby, Connor McDavid, Patrice Bergeron, Nicklas Backstrom, Steven Stamkos or Ryan Getzlaf were all drafted by their current club. Once you get a true No. 1 centre, you don’t trade him, and you do everything in your power to keep him with your franchise for as long as possible.

But, there are exceptions.

In 2015-16, the Columbus Blue Jackets traded their No. 1 centre, Ryan Johansen, to the Nashville Predators in exchange for defenceman Seth Jones.

Because defencemen are at least as highly coveted as top-line centres.

Now back to the Canucks. Bo Horvat is doing his best to develop into a first-line player, but it wouldn’t hurt to get some insurance. Luckily, the Colorado Avalanche have someone available: Matt Duchene.

And they also know what they are seeking in return.

A young, established defenceman and a first-round pick is what it’ll take.

Let’s see what the Canucks can come up with.

Chris Tanev

Get ready for offer No. 1:

Why Vancouver does it:

Chris Tanev is the Canucks’ top defenceman, and he is one of the best shutdown D-men in the league. The 27-year-old is criminally underrated among NHL fans, but general managers and coaches know what he provides. So, there is no doubt that Vancouver would hate to let him go.

However, the Canucks’ defensive group looks relatively strong right now. With Ben Hutton, Nikita Tryamkin, Troy Stecher, Erik Gudbranson, Olli Juolevi and Jordan Subban, they have a solid group of youngsters as well. We don’t know what they will become, but they should be a very good group for many years.

What the Canucks are lacking is offensive firepower, and Duchene would provide that. Getting a first-line centre could take this team a long way.

Why Colorado does it:

Let’s start with a question: How young is “young”? Tanev is only 27, so he should still have a few years in him before he starts to decline. But, if the Avs are specifically asking for a young player, Tanev might be too old to qualify.

Still, Tanev is only a year older than Duchene, and he would become an incredibly important piece of the Avs’ D-core. Like the Canucks, the Avalanche are a terrible possession team. Plus, they rank third-last in goals against. Tanev knows how to keep attackers away from the net, which would be invaluable for Colorado.

Since Duchene still has the higher potential, the Canucks add this year’s first-round draft pick, which will help the Avs assemble more talent for the future.

Ben Hutton

Here’s offer No. 2:

Why Vancouver does it:

Trading Tanev would suck. Trading Ben Hutton would suck just as much. Maybe even more. Hutton is a fan favourite and the kind of player you don’t want to trade.

But, at this point, he is very much expandable. The Canucks currently have Alex Edler, Tryamkin and Luca Sbisa on the left side. None of those players are elite, but they are good enough for now. Plus, Olli Juolevi is expected to join the fold as early as next season. If Tanev, Gudbranson and Stecher all stay, the Canucks are set for at least a couple more years.

Related Story: 5 Players to Watch for 2017 NHL Draft

Why Colorado does it:

Hutton is just 23 years old, which is great. But, he is not as established as Tanev. At times, Hutton still struggles, and so far this season, he has recorded fewer points than Stecher and even Sbisa. To be fair, Sbisa has appeared in nine more games than Hutton, but still.

In Colorado, Hutton could become a solid top-four defenceman for the next seven years or more. Though he may never become a true No. 1 D-man, he should be a strong contributor on the Avs’ blue line. To sweeten the deal, the Canucks add two draft picks that will help improve the team through the draft or via trades.

Embed from Getty Images

Olli Juolevi

The final offer:

Why Vancouver does it:

The Canucks don’t want to go into full-on rebuild mode. That’s totally understandable. One way to avoid it would be to keep young NHL regulars like Hutton and instead trade a prospect and a draft pick for a No. 1 centre.

Olli Juolevi is expected to become a top-pairing player for many years. But, there are no guarantees that he will ever actually make it. The 2016-17 season has not been as good for Juolevi as we would’ve hoped, so there are still some question marks surrounding him.

Related Story: 5 Draft Targets in Playoff Scenario

Why Colorado does it:

Juolevi isn’t established, so he doesn’t exactly fit Adrian Dater’s description. However, he is young, and he has sky-high potential. One NHL defenceman — say, Tanev or Hutton — won’t turn the Avs into a Stanley Cup contender. It might not even be enough to make it to the playoffs.

So, the Avalanche have a lot more work to do. They could try to build their roster around Nathan MacKinnon, Mikko Rantanen and Juolevi, and take it from there.

With the 2017 first-round pick, they could, again, add another talented prospect through the draft, or flip it for another NHL roster player.